March Madness is HERE: Initial Bracket Reactions & Storylines

Published: Mon, 03/17/25

Updated: Mon, 03/17/25

By The Numbers: College Basketball Newsletter
March Madness 2025: Instant Bracket Reactions & Key Storylines
The 2025 NCAA Tournament bracket is here, and we’ve had a few hours to digest the matchups. While we’ll dive deeper into the data and projections soon, here are our instant takeaways from Selection Sunday.
Favorites at the Top, Chaos Below
This year, we have a strong set of No. 1 seeds—our four highest-rated teams earned those top spots. That hasn’t always been the case in past years.

But after the top four? It’s a mess. The No. 8 seeds might actually be stronger than the No. 5-7 seeds, making for some intriguing early-round matchups. If you’re looking for potential bracket chaos, this might be the year to find it in the middle seed lines.
Alabama Injury Concern?
Alabama landed on the No. 2 line, but we’ve slightly downgraded them due to injury concerns. Forward Grant Nelson (11.8 PPG, 7.3 RPG) missed the second half of their SEC Tournament loss to Florida, and his status for the First Round remains unclear.

Head coach Nate Oats didn’t sound overly confident, saying, “Hopefully we get him back.” If Nelson isn’t 100%, Alabama’s path gets much tougher.
Gonzaga: A Dangerous No. 8 Seed?
Gonzaga landing as a No. 8 seed isn’t a shock—their metrics were solid, but they lost most of their key games early in the season. Still, this program has made nine straight Sweet 16s. If history is any indication, the Bulldogs won’t be an easy out.
Defending Champs in the Shadows
UConn isn’t a No. 1 seed, but let’s not forget: They’re the two-time defending national champions. Danny Hurley’s squad had an uneven season, partly due to injuries (Liam McNeeley missed time). But if they’re fully healthy, they’re still a serious contender.
Louisville at No. 8: A Head-Scratcher?
No team was a bigger seeding surprise than Louisville. Bracketologists expected them closer to a No. 6 seed, yet they landed on the No. 8 line.

New head coach Pat Kelsey has transformed this team, and after a slow start, they’ve won 21 of their last 23 games. This is not your typical No. 8 seed.
Duke’s Path Looks Favorable
Once again, Duke gets a solid draw. The Blue Devils won’t face a team rated in our top 30 in the second round.

No. 9 Baylor is undersized after losing a key post player. No. 8 Mississippi State? They’re 0-9 this season against teams in the top 25 in offensive efficiency. Duke fits that profile perfectly.
Colorado State Favored at No. 12?
The betting markets have already spoken—No. 12 Colorado State is actually favored over No. 5 Memphis.

Colorado State is the highest-rated team outside the top 8 seed lines. Memphis? They’re the lowest-rated team inside that group. This might not even be an upset.
Michigan’s Tough Turnaround
Michigan is another No. 5 seed in a tough spot. After playing in the Big Ten title game late Sunday, they now have to fly to Denver and play on Thursday—at elevation—against No. 12 UC-San Diego (30-4).

UCSD is elite at forcing turnovers, while Michigan struggles to take care of the ball (ranking 328th in offensive turnover rate). That’s a dangerous matchup.
Injury Uncertainty Looms Large
This year’s bracket feels more uncertain than usual due to injuries. Several key players are question marks heading into the First Round, including:
Duke (No. 1, East): Cooper Flagg (ankle) missed the last two games but is expected to return.
Alabama (No. 2, East): Grant Nelson (knee) left their last game.
Texas Tech (No. 3, West): Darrion Williams & Chance McMillian missed their last game.
Iowa State (No. 3, South): Keshon Gilbert is out for the tournament; Tamin Lipsey missed the last game.
Kentucky (No. 3, Midwest): Lamont Butler (shoulder) is dealing with a lingering issue.
Clemson (No. 5, Midwest): Dillon Hunter (hand) is out.
Missouri (No. 6, West): Mark Mitchell (knee) missed the SEC Tournament finale.
These injuries could shift expectations in the coming days. Stay tuned—we’ll be monitoring updates and what they mean for the bracket.
Get Expert Bracket Picks Now →
College Hoops Picks for Thursday, March 20:
  • ⭐⭐⭐ Pick
    Michigan -2.5 (vs. UCSD)

    THU @ 10 PM (ET)

  • ⭐⭐⭐ Pick
    Utah St vs. UCLA UNDER 145.5

    THU @ 9:25 PM (ET)

  • ⭐⭐⭐ Pick
    Drake vs. Missouri UNDER 133.5

    THU @ 7:35 PM (ET)
View All Model Picks
Let us help you make the best picks for your bracket this week! Choose from one of our top packages below:
Yearly Subscription — $299
Regular Price: $699 (55% off)

Get betting picks and content for NCAAB, NBA, MLB, NFL, and NCAAF. Includes all pool picks for March Madness, football, and golf. Everything we offer for less than $1 a day!
March Madness Pass — $129
Regular Price: $289 (55% off)

Receive betting picks and content for March Madness 2025, plus all pool picks for men’s and women’s brackets, survivor, and Calcutta. This pass lasts until April 15, 2025.
Pool Picks Subscription — $99
Regular Price: $259 (60% off)

Access pool picks for March Madness (men’s & women’s brackets, survivor, Calcutta) and football (NFL survivor, pick’em, bowl pick’em, Best Ball).
Bracket Picks PLUS — $59
Regular Price: $99 (40% off)

Get men’s and women’s bracket picks, along with men’s NCAA survivor picks for the 2025 season.
Men’s Bracket Picks — $39

Bracket picks and tools exclusively for the 2025 men’s tournament.
Sign Up For Bracket Picks Here

📈 Public Pick % To Win National Champioship

  1. Duke: 26.7%
  2. Florida: 22.7%
  3. Auburn: 11.5%
  4. Houston: 9.7%
  5. St John's: 5.5%

💰 Final Four Odds

  1. Duke: 53%
  2. Houston: 44%
  3. Auburn: 42%
  4. Florida: 38%

🔎 Highest Graded Middle Seeds (5-11)

  1. Kansas: 18.2%
  2. Illinois: 17.8%
  3. Baylor: 16.9%
  4. BYU: 16.9%
  5. Marquette: 16.8%

🏆 Odds To Win Tourney

  1. Duke: 27%
  2. Houston: 16%
  3. Auburn: 14%
  4. Florida: 12%
March Madness First-Round Tip Times

Thursday, March 20
  • 6:50 PM ET | TNT | Lexington
    (15) Wofford vs. (2) Tennessee

  • 7:10 PM ET | CBS | Providence
    (10) Arkansas vs. (7) Kansas

  • 7:25 PM ET | TBS | Denver
    (13) Yale vs. (4) Texas A&M

  • 7:35 PM ET | truTV | Wichita
    (11) Drake vs. (6) Missouri

  • 9:25 PM ET* | TNT | Lexington
    (10) Utah St vs. (7) UCLA

  • 9:45 PM ET* | CBS | Providence
    (15) Omaha vs. (2) St. John’s

  • 10:00 PM ET* | TBS | Denver
    (12) UC San Diego vs. (5) Michigan

  • 10:10 PM ET* | truTV | Wichita
    (14) UNCW vs. (3) Texas Tech

(*Approximate tip times)

Questions or Feedback?

Thanks for subscribing to By the Numbers: College Basketball . Don't hesitate to hit reply if you have questions, comments, or feedback.

Sincerely,
The TeamRankings Crew
support@teamrankings.com

 


111 S Highland Avenue #458
Memphis TN 38111
US


Unsubscribe   |   Change Subscriber Options